pressherald.com · The Portland Press Herald · September 9, 2026
Susan Collins’ ads attack Troy Jackson on affordability. Here’s some context.
Questions about your account? Our customer service team can be reached at circulation@metln.org during business hours at (207) 791-6000 (2077916000).
# Susan Collins’ ads attack Troy Jackson on affordability. Here’s some context.
Collins jabbed Jackson’s record on property taxes and electricity bills in her first round of attack ads last week.
Posted 12:20 PM Updated at 12:20 PM
Ethan Horton Staff Writer
Sen. Susan Collins speaks with reporters after touring Volk Packaging Corporation in Biddeford on Monday. (Staff photo by Derek Davis)
Sen. Susan Collins, R-ME, used the first attack ads of her reelection campaign last week to jab her Democratic opponent, former Senate President Troy Jackson, on affordability.
It’s a salient place to attack. Mainers said in a joint New York Times/Press Herald/Siena poll this summer that the economy and cost of living were among their top considerations this November, and the Trump administration’s continuing trade war with Canada has stretched Maine pockets thinner. Jackson and aligned groups have attacked Collins on affordability, too.
Collins’ new ads targeted Jackson’s record on property taxes. And, echoing another focus of her ads, Collins said in an extended Politico interview released last week that Jackson had overseen a massive rise in electricity prices.
But 30-second spots and quick claims in interviews rarely capture the full picture. Some of the claims in Collins’ ads are misleading.
“Susan Collins can’t defend her own record, so she and her billionaire backers are lying about Troy’s record instead,” Jackson campaign spokesperson David Farmer said. “Voters know that Collins has voted with Trump 96% of the time, she confirmed the justices who overturned Roe v. Wade, and gave Trump and ICE a blank check for $70 billion while greenlighting his disastrous cuts to Medicaid. No matter what they say about Troy, Mainers know that Collins has made their lives harder.”
Jackson’s campaign hasn’t been free from misleading attacks, either. For instance, Jackson has often claimed that Collins supported the One Big Beautiful Bill Act — the centerpiece legislation signed by President Donald Trump last July. That bill contained the Medicaid cuts that Farmer referenced in his statement. Collins voted to advance the bill to the floor, but voted against its enactment.
Let’s look at the broader context of Collins’ affordability attacks on Jackson.
## ‘Troy raised property taxes on seniors’
This was a primary claim of one of Collins’ first ads.
> Susan Collins campaign: "Your property taxes were already too high. Then Troy Jackson made it worse. As President of the Maine Senate, Troy raised property taxes on seniors." pic.twitter.com/ZbTwEMThEN > > — AdImpact Politics (@AdImpact_Pol) September 1, 2026
The spot, which first aired Sept. 1 and has about $160,000 behind it so far, per AdImpact, cites two pieces of legislation from 2023, when Jackson was Senate President.
Lawmakers approved one of them, LD 258, on July 6, 2023. It wasn’t just any bill — it was the two-year $800 million state budget. And it was approved with a 22-9 vote in Jackson’s Senate, with two Republicans joining Democrats.
That state budget, among many other provisions, removed a property tax stabilization program for seniors that capped property taxes at existing levels, with the state reimbursing municipalities for lost income. The program had just been implemented one year prior with little debate and broad bipartisan support, and supporters said the popular program helped seniors on fixed incomes stay in their homes.
But by the summer of 2023, municipalities were struggling under the weight of paperwork. More than 100,000 applications flooded in during the first year. Cost estimates for the state rose from an initial $21 million to $46 million.
The program allowed applications from anyone over the age of 65, regardless of income. Critics pointed out the largest tax breaks went to wealthy homeowners, since there was no test for financial need. Adding in income eligibility requirements was daunting for some municipalities, who would only have more forms to process.
The budget committee decided to replace the senior stabilization program by boosting two other property tax relief initiatives in the 2023 state budget.
One boosted program, the senior property tax deferral program, allows people 65 and older to stop paying their property taxes until they die, move or sell their home. The state reimburses municipalities for lost revenue and places a lien on the home, allowing the town to recoup the unpaid taxes plus interest when the home is sold.
The property tax fairness credit, the other boosted initiative, provides a tax credit for income-eligible Maine residents who paid more than 4% of their income on property taxes or more than 26.67% of their income on rent. People over 65 get enhanced credits.
Republican Sen. Trey Stewart, who introduced the original stabilization program, was one of two GOP senators who voted in favor of the budget that repealed it.
LR 2779, also cited in the ad, was a subsequent effort by Sen. Russell Black, R-Franklin, to revive the stabilization program, with new eligibility requirements for financial need.
That effort was shot down by legislative leaders, including Jackson, later that year, and it never saw the floor of the Legislature.
## ‘Mainers paid more on property taxes than any other state’
This is another central claim of Collins’ attack ads.
This ad, which started airing earlier this month, cites the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, which studies property taxes around the country. In 2020 and 2021, no state paid more personal income toward property taxes than Maine, the Lincoln Institute found.
Data provided to the Legislature’s Real Estate Property Tax Relief Task Force in October shows Maine is no longer at the top of the list, but still ranked in the top five in 2023. WalletHub’s latest analysis has Maine in fifth place for property tax burden, with the average household paying almost 4% of their income on local taxes.
Collins’ ad attributes Maine’s high ranking to “Troy Jackson’s failed leadership in Augusta.” The Lincoln Institute, in testimony to the Legislature, suggested it was more specifically due to a combination of infrequent property revaluations, reliance on local property tax and caps on values.
Others, including Republican gubernatorial nominee Bobby Charles, have said lawmakers have put too many unfunded mandates on municipalities and counties, leaving local leaders no recourse but to raise property taxes.
## ‘Under Troy Jackson’s leadership in Augusta, electric rates have skyrocketed’
Consumer spending on electricity has indeed increased significantly since 2019, the first year Jackson was in charge of the Maine Senate.
Mainers were spending about 40% more per kilowatt hour when Jackson left office in 2024 than they were in 2019, data from the U.S. Energy Information Administration shows.
> Susan Collins Joint Fundraising Committee: "Under Troy Jackson's failed leadership in Augusta, Maine's electricity rates skyrocketed, the highest increase in the nation, so you get shocked with every bill." pic.twitter.com/QlJIKzIEQF > > — AdImpact Politics (@AdImpact_Pol) September 1, 2026
The claim that Maine’s electricity bills went up the highest in the nation came from a federal report compiled by Axios that showed Maine’s electricity costs had gone up 36% between May 2024 and May 2025.
But Maine’s Public Advocate, Heather Sanborn, was unable last year to reproduce that analysis using state-level numbers, which use actual bills. The federal calculation that Axios reported was instead based on utility revenue and the amount of electricity provided.
Electricity rates are a complicated combination of supply, delivery and public policy costs, and those rates are regulated by the three